Sorry for the long post in advance fellas. This is my last decision so figured I'd get other people's input! Which combo do people like out of:
1) Rich Nicnat S.Gray
vs
2) Brodie Stef S.Gray
vs
3) Brodie Stef Buddy
vs
4) Yeo Stef Buddy
vs
5) Yeo Nicnat Buddy
- Rich should be good in a full time midfield role but he has had plenty of years (many in the midfield) and has averaged 90 just once. People selecting him would essentially be expecting a career best year for him to be a good pick
- Refuse to believe Brodie's as bad as he was last season and the concussions definitely knocked him around (http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport...s/news-story/d62c37896969767036f19181b339251a). Has the potential to average 95+
- Yeo stunk it up in the back half of last season but played in a lockdown role given the injuries. Played an excellent freewheeling role in the NAB games but failed to score well in 2/3 games. A massive risk vs reward selection given his ability to go big (but also very small)
- In the rucks, Stef is a safe 110+ option (particularly with no 2nd ruck) but Nicnat is capable of averaging similar numbers if he puts it together
- Buddy once again a big risk and I'm inclined not to take it but we all know what he's capable of doing. Gray still has a question mark in terms of role and therefore his ability to score well consistently but I quite like him and am happy to roll the dice there.
Leaning towards option 1 but get the feeling options 3 or 4 have the most potential. They all require different combinations of 2 of Mccarthy/Hewett/Papley, but given the uncertainty around these guys I'd rather concentrate on being happy with my on field players.
1) Rich Nicnat S.Gray
vs
2) Brodie Stef S.Gray
vs
3) Brodie Stef Buddy
vs
4) Yeo Stef Buddy
vs
5) Yeo Nicnat Buddy
- Rich should be good in a full time midfield role but he has had plenty of years (many in the midfield) and has averaged 90 just once. People selecting him would essentially be expecting a career best year for him to be a good pick
- Refuse to believe Brodie's as bad as he was last season and the concussions definitely knocked him around (http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport...s/news-story/d62c37896969767036f19181b339251a). Has the potential to average 95+
- Yeo stunk it up in the back half of last season but played in a lockdown role given the injuries. Played an excellent freewheeling role in the NAB games but failed to score well in 2/3 games. A massive risk vs reward selection given his ability to go big (but also very small)
- In the rucks, Stef is a safe 110+ option (particularly with no 2nd ruck) but Nicnat is capable of averaging similar numbers if he puts it together
- Buddy once again a big risk and I'm inclined not to take it but we all know what he's capable of doing. Gray still has a question mark in terms of role and therefore his ability to score well consistently but I quite like him and am happy to roll the dice there.
Leaning towards option 1 but get the feeling options 3 or 4 have the most potential. They all require different combinations of 2 of Mccarthy/Hewett/Papley, but given the uncertainty around these guys I'd rather concentrate on being happy with my on field players.
Last edited:
