X v. Y

[Tevez17]

Crouch. It would be a closer contest if there weren't so many back rookies and so few mid rookies. His scoring history is easy on the eyes too.

So many back rookies? I agree there's a few but job security &/or scoring potential of the 117k guys (Brown, Hartley, Broad, Adams, Collins) is highly questionable & the mid rookies can be covered to an extent by the Fwd/Mid rookies,

This is basically the last piece of the jigsaw for me pretty much put a line through Steele, so it's Dea and Weitering V Crouch, Crouch is in atm but me defence looks so much more solid with Weitering D5 and Dea D6.

 

[Dr Bones]

Guns & Rookies a much safer bet

 

[Ltv]

Brodie Smith or Daniel Rich, Or any other defenders around the 400-450k mark?

 

[bat]

So many back rookies? I agree there's a few but job security &/or scoring potential of the 117k guys (Brown, Hartley, Broad, Adams, Collins) is highly questionable & the mid rookies can be covered to an extent by the Fwd/Mid rookies,

This is basically the last piece of the jigsaw for me pretty much put a line through Steele, so it's Dea and Weitering V Crouch, Crouch is in atm but me defence looks so much more solid with Weitering D5 and Dea D6.

Hopefully team sheets will give you bit more confidence.

Dea, Adams, Weitering, Brown, Hartley all look good for JS in my eyes.

Then you have Tippa, Collins, Ruggles (maybe even Byrne-Jones) all in with a good chance.

 

[Steve]

Weitering + Grimley

or

M. Brown + Currie

Have had Currie locked at R3 since day 1. Have resisted the temptation to get Weitering in up til this point but somehow my defence looks a lot more solid with him at D5.

 

[Brad]

Pedlebury and c Oliver

Or

A hall and t green

?????

I'm split on which wat to go

 

[Prospector]

First one.

 

[doddy2731]

Watch Oliver's JS

 

[TomCat]

Pedlebury and c Oliver

Or

A hall and t green

?????

I'm split on which wat to go

First option easily imo.

 

[Brad]

First option easily imo.

Only reason I'm not sure is coz it will make wells my f3 Kennedy f4 menadue f5 and Kerridge f6 or do u think that would be OK

 

[Jack19]

Huge Question:

Mcevoy, Ablett, Weitering

or

Gawn, Rich, Libba

 

[TomCat]

Only reason I'm not sure is coz it will make wells my f3 Kennedy f4 menadue f5 and Kerridge f6 or do u think that would be OK

Fine by me. I had the same structure until recently and there is a good chance that I will go back to it.

If it makes you feel better I was just listening to the podcast and all of the guys consider these rookies as locks and recommend having them on the field.

 

[tabs]

Huge Question:

Mcevoy, Ablett, Weitering

or

Gawn, Rich, Libba

2nd choice as McEvoy is a worse pick than the Dons for the flag

 

[mdola2]

I've decided that I just can't start without Goldstein. Two expensive rookies on the chopping block since I can't afford both.
Weitering v B Kennedy?

 

[Brad]

I've decided that I just can't start without Goldstein. Two expensive rookies on the chopping block since I can't afford both.
Weitering v B Kennedy?

i see more upside to kennedy personally
i have both in my team at the moment but if i had to make the choice

 

[bat]

Okay, with the bad news about Beams, I'm thinking.

Lonergan/Sheridan vs Weitering/Rich

 

[Benj]

Fyfe and Libba vs Shiel and Duncan???????

This is doing my head in! I know Fyfe and Libba is the obvious and most talked about combo but I can't decide whether to lock them or pick two blokes who I really love to watch and I think will have great years. I should say that I already have B Crouch too so there's already some risk in my mids. Thoughts would be appreciated.

 

[Prospector]

Fyfe and Libba

... or be happy when the season is over early - less risk, longer life.

 

[smirski]

Pendles, Hall and B crouch
vs
Fyfe, S Gray and Oliver

 

[currymunchers]

Pendles, Hall and B crouch
vs
Fyfe, S Gray and Oliver

I'd go Pendles Hall Crouch. I've got them at 120, 95 and 100 (315) and the other combo at 125, 95 and 75-80 (295-300). Need to remember Brayshaw isn't playing this week so an average game from Oliver could see him in the 2's next week.