X v. Y
- Thread starter Prospector
- Start date
JJK and Cyril for me. Reckon Gunston might struggle with Roughy out, and Hill has never averaged better than 77 and I don't see any reason why he'd start now
I'm praying Gunston struggles without Roughy... Potentially a nice and cheap pick up late
Agreed w/ J-Dog. JJ over Gunstall ... too much doubt to start him with Roughy out, right?
I can't even start to make a case for Hill or Cyril. Care to share your thinking there?
Not starting either atm, just felt there were some similarities. JJK has a guernsey so far.
Its a tough one. I have Danger in the side atm, mostly hoping for big things at the Cats. Collingwood have a tough first few rounds, so maybe I can get off to a flyer?
JJK, Cyril and Pendles for me.
JJK over Gunston but wouldnt touch either. More inclined to go with Darling instead.
Cyril over Hill but will Cyril play 20+ games ?
Pendles v Danger is a tight one . Going Pendles only because not sure how Danger will mould in to the cats game plan. Jelwood needs help but danger needs good ball to do his work.
What about Mummy v NicNat??
JJK over Gunston but wouldnt touch either. More inclined to go with Darling instead.
Cyril over Hill but will Cyril play 20+ games ?
Pendles v Danger is a tight one . Going Pendles only because not sure how Danger will mould in to the cats game plan. Jelwood needs help but danger needs good ball to do his work.
What about Mummy v NicNat??
Which gets injured first? I think NacNats power and follow up puts him ahead here.
They sizzle and spit - its all about when, and in what direction!
If mummy fit he creams nic nat as a ruckman. Last 4 years, albeit some injuries for both, mummy averages more disp, marks, hit outs and tackles per game than nic nat. His avg disp eff over those years is about 76% and nic nat's is about 66%. My concern is that although nic scored great last year his numbers in all catergories except h/outs dropped from the previous year in a year when they made a GF, won a lot of games for a top four finish and i would suggest that this year maybe priddis might get tagged finally which could impact on the h/out to adv points which obviously make up most his score, as with an avg of 11.7 disp, 1.4 marks and 3.6 tackles a game in 2015 with a disp eff of 61.9% he aint getting many points there! Mummy for me - better natural football player, team on the rise and a bit of mongrel in him.
