X v. Y
- Thread starter Prospector
- Start date
Liba i will hold for the year, the others i will monitor and upgrade to prems when the prems have bottomed out.
I think Hunter and Lloyd can increase their output and average 95+
I think if Llooyd, and Hunter can get over 90, Liba over 100 and Crouch almost 100, then that can outscore 2 prems and 2 rookies
Got a bit of a triple layered one here
Gibson or KK & J.Steele
Vs
Sheridan or Lonergan & T.Greene
Gibson or KK & J.Steele
Vs
Sheridan or Lonergan & T.Greene
Excellent choices ... not sure I can split 'em.
- First off, I like Gibson over Sheridan. It's the other 4 I can't get satisfied on ... oh, and that ...
- ... numbering is automatic - I didn't mean or want to start a numbered list! and um ...
- ... I fear I'm not interpreting the question correctly, and ...
- ... I'd take Greene over Steele ...
- ... and ... Sheridan v. Lonergan is a nice choice. Stick with just one of them in your side ...
- ... you name who and lets see if I agree!
Last edited:
Hmm I'm torn on this one... I really like the prospect of Steele taking over Treloars role, he's a tackling machine. I'm leaning towards Gibson over KK or Sheridan over Lonergan, I think it will come down to what mood I'm in come lockout!!
First up, I am utterly mystified over why Greene is getting any interest at all. He has poor DE, hasn't had a role change, and is likely to score the same if not worse than last year. Why is he even in the frame?
Gibson and Steele for mine
Gibson and Steele for mine
Big Statement! Pls. provide the better forward options that fit every structure.
I am simply questioning Greene. I am not going to wax lyrical on every other option, but IMO Steele is 50/50 to average higher for the season as he is a much better kick, is equally hard at the footy and appears to be a genuine mid as opposed to Greene who is a forward who roams around a bit. In many ways Steele reminds me of Ollie Wines. I would select Hall or Sam Gray in front of Greene as both have a more SC friendly role and both have shown signs of playing & scoring like mids. I know it's SuperCoach and I could be wildly wrong, but Greene seems a very odd pick to me as his upside appears so small.
Stevie J coming in to the fwds and Treloar out of the mids. This could spell more mid time for greene the tackling machine
He will have a roll tweak no doubt, with Johnson and Smith playing forward and more Mids resting forward he'll get more Mid rotations, don't forget GWS know what they have in Greene and as such no need to test him in the midfield too much during the preseason where'as Steele needed time in the middle.
Imo Steele isn't a great kick but his tackling pressure is fantastic and he finds the ball pretty well, I'd have Hall then Steele then Green in that order but the difference between the latter 2 is simply their price I think Greene will probably average a little more than Steele.
Libba, Mills 125K Rookie
Vs
Mills, Oliver & Parish (& 72k to spend elsewhere)
Keep in mind I think Parish will have a good first year something like 15 games at 80.
Feeling most will say option 1 but just in case thought i'd ask.
Vs
Mills, Oliver & Parish (& 72k to spend elsewhere)
Keep in mind I think Parish will have a good first year something like 15 games at 80.
Feeling most will say option 1 but just in case thought i'd ask.
Apart from Dea in the backs and Polk when injury free i dont really want to select any dons players.
Hence why im going Option 1. Also Liba plus a playing $125k rookie will outscore Parish and Oliver.
Can you get extra money from somewhere to turn the $125k rookie in to Oliver?
Hence why im going Option 1. Also Liba plus a playing $125k rookie will outscore Parish and Oliver.
Can you get extra money from somewhere to turn the $125k rookie in to Oliver?
Depends a little on R1 selection but most likely it'd have to come from B Kennedy, McCarthy, Menadue ect
B Crouch instead of Libba would probably work.
I've been pretty set on my rucks but now I'm considering a change. My two options and their repercussions down back are:
1) R2 Martin and D4 Weitering
vs
2) R2 Nic Nat and D4 Lonergan
Option 2 feels like more risk but I'm leaning towards it. Thoughts appreciated.
1) R2 Martin and D4 Weitering
vs
2) R2 Nic Nat and D4 Lonergan
Option 2 feels like more risk but I'm leaning towards it. Thoughts appreciated.