Search results

  1. TwentyThree

    X v. Y

    Nice. I don't think the Z.Smith pick is crazy. Didn't like KK's NABs. Safer option - 2nd one. Risk/reward - 1st. I'd go 2nd, just.
  2. TwentyThree

    JJ,'mr burn' hurn or the cheaper lonergan

    I had Hurn in a draft comp last year. He was terrible. Eagles also have a really tough fixture. Dogs have a tough one too. I like Lonergan. I'd rate them Lonergan, Sheridan, Hurn, JJ.
  3. TwentyThree

    Keeper league.

    Yeah really disappointing @doddy2731 but thanks for going to all the effort of setting up the league and the rules et al. I think we have the right structure in place, so hopefully we can have another dip next year with a bit more luck! In better news, your team is 3-0 for the year!
  4. TwentyThree

    Rookies 2016

    Has Charlie been hurt over the PS?
  5. TwentyThree

    Rookies 2016

    Adelaide are raving about Milera, wonder if he's a bit slight / young, tho he was great playing senior SANFL footy late last year. I think one of Menadue and Corey Ellis will come off...just a matter of which one?!
  6. TwentyThree

    Defenders 2016

    Quick note from the Prospectus on Marley's ball use... "...Williams' kicking has to improve for him to take the next step...it was the eighth-worst of the top-30 rebound kicks for his position..." Freako added "needs to improve his kicking before he can be considered as a starter." I...
  7. TwentyThree

    Midfield 2016

    Don't mind your risk-reward there. I think it's a 'good risk', if that makes sense. Could come off + easy enough to fix.
  8. TwentyThree

    Forwards 2016

    The Chad went past 100 in 11 of the last 16 games last year, with another score of 99 and two in the 80's. Played pretty deep in an average side. I don't think he'll let you down. Jack Martin...if only he could stay on the park. He'll be a brilliant pick one day. Just wanna see a consistent...
  9. TwentyThree

    Keeper league.

    I'm in guys. 8 would be great.
  10. TwentyThree

    Defenders 2016

    This article contends they only get 2 further rookie elevations...? http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/essendon/jake-long-and-anthony-mcdonaldtipungwuti-eyeing-place-on-essendons-senior-list/news-story/9b721e96c3995dc08da998c33ebfb6d8
  11. TwentyThree

    Rucks 2016

    I don't think he's very good at football.
  12. TwentyThree

    Defenders 2016

    Dea top scored for them today. Worth a look. Hartley scored well again. Brown not so much. Good day up there?
  13. TwentyThree

    Keeper league.

    Agree on all points @doddy2731 . I'd go for free kicks for and against to be inversely equal (2 and -2 maybe) but I'm happy with 1 / -2 as well. Looking forward to a solid group signing up and giving this format a crack!
  14. TwentyThree

    The year of the midpricer

    Classic. I'd love to see you start this team and then see what it looks like by seasons end.
  15. TwentyThree

    Midfield 2016

    Like him. Get 22 games consistently. Tackles, clearances, contested possessions. Has played 22, 22, 21, 20, 22, 19, 20, 18 & 22 (h & a) games since '06 (his debut year, where he played 2).
  16. TwentyThree

    Forwards 2016

    Prestia hurt too. Lonergen hurt last night. No Swallow. No JOM. GC in disarray (again).
  17. TwentyThree

    Keeper league.

    Yes me, sorry fellas. I'm in for sure, just a bit flat-stick at the moment!
  18. TwentyThree

    Midfield 2016

    I think Lonergen is a fine pick in the backline, given his elite junior history, high draft choice, a couple years in the system and seemingly poised for a role change (helped by multiple injuries to players ahead of him).
  19. TwentyThree

    Defenders 2016

    That was my impression too, thought he'd be borderline best 22, but seen him in enough teams to question myself.
  20. TwentyThree

    Forwards 2016

    Denzel is an outstanding nickname.