Round 4 Trades

[cactus]

Of course I didn't really answer your question.

Crouch is a write off so I'm trading to Parker or an equivalent. I have to sacrifice Lonergan but so be it. Hopefully not too big a loss.

Rich - I can see why you'd bail but I'd probably hold if I was in your possie.

 

[ThanksForComing]

Rich - hold or trade to Burgoyne?

Toby Greene - who to trade to, no viable options around similar price?

 

[M4TT B8S]

Rich - hold or trade to Burgoyne?

Hold.

 

[cactus]

Rich - hold or trade to Burgoyne?

Toby Greene - who to trade to, no viable options around similar price?

In the past I think Burgoyne has only really scored strongly when the Hawks have singnificant midfield out so if you're looking for a good season long keeper he'd be a "no" for me. Also I reckon I'd be holding Rich.

 

[Brad]

Almost the same delemma I'm struggling with except I'd be trading out Lonergan and Brad Crouch. Would leave me with 26 trades and basically the same backline and midfield as you except I have Bartel for your Laird.

Seems like a more clear cut good idea for me because Brad Crouch is clearly a right off. Rich won't cop any tags harder than Jacobs and he could still score at keeper backline level.

Interested why you're picking Parker as the man to bring in. I just posted in x vs y and I'm really struggling to know which mid primo to get this week.

I'm only looking a parker at his price he seems to be a great pick and with the mids I already have I don't really see a better option who else r you considering ??? Priddis maybe Selwood

 

[cactus]

I'm only looking a parker at his price he seems to be a great pick and with the mids I already have I don't really see a better option who else r you considering ??? Priddis maybe Selwood

Titch? But yeah they seem to be the main contenders.

 

[simon87]

Going to trade Lonergan to Ruggles, but don't know whether to trade B.Crouch to Hall or a premium mid like Priddis, any recommendations?

 

[hawker]

Rich - hold or trade to Burgoyne?

Toby Greene - who to trade to, no viable options around similar price?

Tricky situation, I wouldn't be sideways trading either around that price, they would be better as a hold.

If going to trade out either then you would need to go up or down. You might possibly entertain Rich down to one of the Defender rookies on the bubble next week eg Ruggles if you really want to trade him. Otherwise I would look to work him up to Houli or Laird.

 

[hawker]

Going to trade Lonergan to Ruggles, but don't know whether to trade B.Crouch to Hall or a premium mid like Priddis, any recommendations?

Watch out on the Priddis selection as he may miss this week - http://www.watoday.com.au/afl/west-...jury-before-tigers-clash-20160413-go534h.html

I would hold of a week on Lonergan to Ruggles as there will be no price rise for a week.

Can you do Crouch to Hall without the downgrade?

 

[simon87]

Watch out on the Priddis selection as he may miss this week - http://www.watoday.com.au/afl/west-...jury-before-tigers-clash-20160413-go534h.html

I would hold of a week on Lonergan to Ruggles as there will be no price rise for a week.

Can you do Crouch to Hall without the downgrade?

Cheers!
88k in the bank so a bit short for Hall, not really sure what way I can move!
Here's my team:
DEF: Shaw, Houli, Laird, Lonergan, Weitering, Adams, Hartley, Brown
MID: Dangerfield, R.Gray, Ablett, Pendlebury, Liberatore, B.Crouch, Parish, Mills, Menadue, Davis, Gresham
RUCK: Goldstein, Naitanui, Goetz
FWD: Martin, Barlow, Wells, Kennedy, Kerridge, Papley, Milera, McDonald-Tipungwuti

 

[Brad]

Titch? But yeah they seem to be the main contenders.

It's hard with Syd mids they all score well feel Parker is more proven the torch titch tho but I could be wrong hard to tell with Syd mids

 

[captainchardonnay]

Rich - hold or trade to Burgoyne?

Toby Greene - who to trade to, no viable options around similar price?

Hold & hold. Chasing last weeks points and the car. Having an extra trade up your sleeve come red 19 will be worth more than both.

 

[jester5au]

Main issue for me is Mills at M8 with BCrouch, Menadue and Gresham on the bench. Think I might drop Gresham due to poor JS and probably won't make much cash even when he does play. Move Lonergan to M8 and then bring in a defence rookie.

Menadue I'll persist with hoping for a big game in the next couple of weeks to boost his price. Crouch I'm also persisting with for now, even though he'll probably miss the next couple as his scoring should improve as the season goes on and planning for him to be my M8 at the end of the year.

Question is Hartley V Ruggles?? Hartley's JS looks shaky with Grima a potential in this week or next which concerns me. Ruggles JS looks good and scoring looks good too, but has only played 1. Ideally Hartley this week and Ruggles in for Brown next week if he has another sub-50 game would be the way I'd like to go.

I already have Hartley. I like his scoring. Should be consistent for a 70. Not sure what effect grima will have potentially it could be brown who makes way.

I'm also looking at moving lonergan into the mids and getting rid of mills. Just doesn't seem to be SC relevant yet. I've toyed with the idea of trading Gresham to Lyons. This gives me a mid def and mid fwd in positions 7&8. It allows extra cover, and the potential to use someone like a lonergan to be upgraded in 3 lines if necessary.

I'll definitely wait til next week to do this move to allow another mills cash rise.

 

[captainchardonnay]

It's hard with Syd mids they all score well feel Parker is more proven the torch titch tho but I could be wrong hard to tell with Syd mids

Rubbish. This theory that @Fbdonkey has is a phalacy. Sydney has a shit backline right? Well guess where those points go? Into the mids. No dominate ruck? Yep, same again. Sydney has a dominant midfield and when they're winning, it's not unusual to see 4, 5, or 6 of them hit the ton. Parker is breaking out massively. He would of done it last year had he not been concussed and injured last year. If you're not on the train already, it's going to burn you all year. Contested beast that hits the scoreboard. SuperCoach royalty.

 

[jester5au]

I have Brad Crouch and only $41k in the bank? Do I hold, downgrade or upgrade?

I would only downgrade him to petracca. Either way they'll both be on your bench and then use the cash to either wait or do an upgrade

 

[Dino]

I would only downgrade him to petracca. Either way they'll both be on your bench and then use the cash to either wait or do an upgrade

I was looking at downgrading Crouch to say Parish or Oliver. I wasn't overly sold on the idea and I hadn't considered someone like Petracca. A bit dangerous as Pertracca could get injured and its a wasted trade. Take a risk or hold. Damn Crouch and his dodgy injuries.

 

[Brad]

Rubbish. This theory that @Fbdonkey has is a phalacy. Sydney has a shit backline right? Well guess where those points go? Into the mids. No dominate ruck? Yep, same again. Sydney has a dominant midfield and when they're winning, it's not unusual to see 4, 5, or 6 of them hit the ton. Parker is breaking out massively. He would of done it last year had he not been concussed and injured last year. If you're not on the train already, it's going to burn you all year. Contested beast that hits the scoreboard. SuperCoach royalty.

I was just saying I like Parker over titch that's all they r all guns no doubt about it

 

[jester5au]

I was looking at downgrading Crouch to say Parish or Oliver. I wasn't overly sold on the idea and I hadn't considered someone like Petracca. A bit dangerous as Pertracca could get injured and its a wasted trade. Take a risk or hold. Damn Crouch and his dodgy injuries.

There's always the threat of injury even to a parish or Oliver who knows how long their bodies will stand up to the rigours of afl. Petracca looks ready made and has another year on both of them. Just my two cents. I moved crouch to Parker last week.

 

[Fbdonkey]

Rubbish. This theory that @Fbdonkey has is a phalacy. Sydney has a shit backline right? Well guess where those points go? Into the mids. No dominate ruck? Yep, same again. Sydney has a dominant midfield and when they're winning, it's not unusual to see 4, 5, or 6 of them hit the ton. Parker is breaking out massively. He would of done it last year had he not been concussed and injured last year. If you're not on the train already, it's going to burn you all year. Contested beast that hits the scoreboard. SuperCoach royalty.

Even JPK has only averaged over 115 once and no other Sydney mid has in recent times.

Parker may not have dominant defenders or rucks competing with him for points but JPK, Hannebery, Titch, Jack, Buddy, McVeigh and Tippet all have the potential to push a 100+ avg

He is a gun and fun to cheer for. Hope he works out

 

[captainchardonnay]

Even JPK has only averaged over 115 once and no other Sydney mid has in recent times.

Parker may not have dominant defenders or rucks competing with him for points but JPK, Hannebery, Titch, Jack, Buddy, McVeigh and Tippet all have the potential to push a 100+ avg

He is a gun and fun to cheer for. Hope he works out

He is going to be the guy that breaks your heart not having him.