Midfielders

[Azza Jones]

Considering swapping Kelly for Treloar at the moment.

Just have a gut feel that Kelly won't be the rolled gold keeper everyone's thinking he will be. Teams playing the Pies are more likely to lock down Sidebottom or even Beams?

Do you have Coniglio? If not I would swap Kelly to him

 

[BingeThinker]

If he's a keeper, you'll be sad to have left him out ...

Does anyone really think Sam Walsh will be a keeper?
At best he is the last rookie upgraded, although given his price and likely quicker price rise or the need to have a quicker price rise due to his inflated starting price, the likelihood is that he gets upgraded during the byes barring injuries.
It is more the quick cash generation to a premo that would have me worried about not starting him?

 

[J-Dog]

Does anyone really think Sam Walsh will be a keeper?
At best he is the last rookie upgraded, although given his price and likely quicker price rise or the need to have a quicker price rise due to his inflated starting price, the likelihood is that he gets upgraded during the byes barring injuries.
It is more the quick cash generation to a premo that would have me worried about not starting him?

I get where you’re coming from with Walsh, I was fairly strong on not starting him most of the preseason but he swayed me with his JLT form. At his price I think we need a minimum 80 average to be worth it, but after seeing him in action it seems there’s a reasonable chance he gets that. So he should make 150-200k and be a reliable on-field rookie scorer, which is pretty hard not to select

 

[Nicko]

Thoughts in Shiel at M5 as a bit of a POD, probably a bit risky i guess but oh well. Or should i just go Libba, cheaper option.

 

[Bombers56]

Thoughts in Shiel at M5 as a bit of a POD, probably a bit risky i guess but oh well. Or should i just go Libba, cheaper option.

Would certainly be a pod, not sure if you will get as much cash growth though?

 

[J-Dog]

Thoughts in Shiel at M5 as a bit of a POD, probably a bit risky i guess but oh well. Or should i just go Libba, cheaper option.

Don’t pick him just for the sake of picking a POD. If you see some value and think he can average 105+ then he might be worth a gamble, but given he’s only gone over 100 once before (101 in 2015) it seems unlikely

 

[Nicko]

Don’t pick him just for the sake of picking a POD. If you see some value and think he can average 105+ then he might be worth a gamble, but given he’s only gone over 100 once before (101 in 2015) it seems unlikely

Yeah true, i just feel like my team is too generic aha.

 

[J-Dog]

Yeah true, i just feel like my team is too generic aha.

Generic doesn’t have to be a bad thing though. My strategy is to just pick the players I believe will score the most, regardless of whether they’re in 1% of teams or 80%

 

[Elliot H-R]

btw does anyone have a group code for supercoachcoach?

 

[Prospector]

i just feel like my team is too generic aha.

Mine's cookie cutter. I reckon that's an even start, and I'll trade from here to improve.

 

[doddy2731]

btw does anyone have a group code for supercoachcoach?

Try this mate.. 558967

 

[Prospector]

Try this mate.. 558967

Thx @doddy2731

 

[Lowrider]

I get where you’re coming from with Walsh, I was fairly strong on not starting him most of the preseason but he swayed me with his JLT form. At his price I think we need a minimum 80 average to be worth it, but after seeing him in action it seems there’s a reasonable chance he gets that. So he should make 150-200k and be a reliable on-field rookie scorer, which is pretty hard not to select

Reckon he'll outdo JOM's first year of 90.1. This might be the last time we see him under $500k....

 

[Elliot H-R]

not sure if this is the right place to post it but,

Treloar/Conigilio + Duursma vs Rockliff/B Crouch + Hanley?

thanks

 

[alrighty then]

not sure if this is the right place to post it but,

Treloar/Conigilio + Duursma vs Rockliff/B Crouch + Hanley?

thanks

I'd personally go with the top option. Rockliff, Crouch And Hanley all have question marks so the probability that 1 doesn't work out is very high and all may not work out.

The first option has 2 premiums with upside to improve and a cheap rookie who if named Rd.1, should increase 8n price

 

[J-Dog]

not sure if this is the right place to post it but,

Treloar/Conigilio + Duursma vs Rockliff/B Crouch + Hanley?

thanks

Option 1 for me as well, Guns and Rookies

 

[Elliot H-R]

This one is gonna cause headaches... Sheed vs Rockliff vs B Crouch?

 

[Azza Jones]

This one is gonna cause headaches... Sheed vs Rockliff vs B Crouch?

Crouch, Sheed then Rocky. Personally I would touch rocky

 

[Nicko]

Is Macrae a lock? A lot of money but he killed me last year.

 

[m4ttdog]

Is Macrae a lock? A lot of money but he killed me last year.

Too expensive for mine.

I think there are better options elsewhere.