Round 19 Trades

[Tevez17]

Imagine most are only sidewaysing for injuries at this point... Not me unfortunately.

Looking to move Mitch Duncan on I think, you take a punt at the start of the season and sometimes it just doesn't come off, Who to bring in is the question bringing Hanners in 3 weeks back hasn't exactly gone well, so very gun shy.

 

[Steve]

Deledio is apparently out "indefinitely". Thanks for the ride Lids. Welcome to the "never again" club.

 

[doddy2731]

Deledio is apparently out "indefinitely". Thanks for the ride Lids. Welcome to the "never again" club.

I had him for 2 weeks (these last 2 ) took him over Gunstan. He will be joining that same heap as yours Steve.

 

[Steve]

I had him for 2 weeks (these last 2 ) took him over Gunstan. He will be joining that same heap as yours Steve.

I had Dahlhaus earmarked for that spot until he went down. Now he might end up there anyway.

I've got Hall, Deledio and Libba, all awkwardly unsurprised and all need attention. 4 trades left, something has to give.

 

[Prospector]

I had Dahlhaus earmarked for that spot until he went down. Now he might end up there anyway.

I've got Hall, Deledio and Libba, all awkwardly unsurprised and all need attention. 4 trades left, something has to give.

i just know you'll be making good decisions here, Steve. Please keep sharing your whys and wherefors - then we all learn!

 

[Tevez17]

Shame about Lids though he had one more good run in him, looking for a replacement from Adelaide I think, they've been very even all season most of the team scoring between 70-105 but they should spike with some big scores over the next 3 weeks then the derby after that.

 

[captainchardonnay]

I might need to hold on Dahl for a week. BE of 188 and I'd really like to see him play a game.

 

[cactus]

Shame about Lids though he had one more good run in him, looking for a replacement from Adelaide I think, they've been very even all season most of the team scoring between 70-105 but they should spike with some big scores over the next 3 weeks then the derby after that.

So ... is Jenkins the one you're considering? *fishing*

 

[Steve]

I might need to hold on Dahl for a week. BE of 188 and I'd really like to see him play a game.

Yep. Esp. Against Geelong , doubt he will score highly this week so a big drop is on the cards.

 

[Tevez17]

So ... is Jenkins the one you're considering? *fishing*

Yeah definitely an option my worry with him is he probbaly has to kick 15+ goals over 3 weeks to get that 115-120ave I'm looking for, I was more leaning to Lynch

 

[Tevez17]

If you guys had Mitch Duncan what would you do with him?

His average (not including his injury game) Isn't horrific but also far from premium, if I didn't have Shiel & T.Mitchell, also B Crouch as bench cover I'd happily keep him as M8/9 but with so many sub premos I just feel I have to move him on the worry is I picked him for a reason, he has big scores in him, I know it!

 

[Dash]

5 Trades left - 129k. Cemented in top four and any other options appreciated.
Def: Shaw, Mcveigh, Bartel, Laird, Simpson, Rich (S Collins, O McDonald)
Mid: Danger, Pendles, Ward, Hanners, Rockliff, Gray, Priddis, S Thompson (J Smith, Trengove, T Phillips)
Ruck: Gawn, S Martin (Grimley)
Fwd: D Martin, Wells, Montagna, Zorko, Petracca, Tippa (DELEDIO, HALL)
Option 1: Hold, do nothing this week.
Option 2: Deledio for someone or S Thompson for someone.
Option 3: Swing Rich into midfield and grab another good defender.
Option 4: Make a downgrade
Thanks.

 

[captainchardonnay]

5 Trades left - 129k. Cemented in top four and any other options appreciated.
Def: Shaw, Mcveigh, Bartel, Laird, Simpson, Rich (S Collins, O McDonald)
Mid: Danger, Pendles, Ward, Hanners, Rockliff, Gray, Priddis, S Thompson (J Smith, Trengove, T Phillips)
Ruck: Gawn, S Martin (Grimley)
Fwd: D Martin, Wells, Montagna, Zorko, Petracca, Tippa (DELEDIO, HALL)
Option 1: Hold, do nothing this week.
Option 2: Deledio for someone or S Thompson for someone.
Option 3: Swing Rich into midfield and grab another good defender.
Option 4: Make a downgrade
Thanks.

1. I hate you.

2. Concentrate on fwds. Get Zerett if you can.

3. I hate you.

 

[qarocks]

4 trades left, Hall and Lids to go. (Currently 1550 trying to get into the top 100, 2450+ last 2 weeks)

Can swap to Franklin/Monty - all the top teams have these two. So unpredictable.
Can't see Dahl banging out a 100+ first game back, has he even played VFL? Probably need at least 1-2 games to get back to form, so basically, forget it unless you are a madman.
Tracca could score another 85+ this week against GC, at the MCG, could hold a trade?

Tough times.

 

[Steve]

Everyone seems lost this week. Lots of big calls to make.

I was going to be conservative but doing that for most of the year has left me stalled around 8k and between 4th and 6th in most of my leagues. So I think I'll go bang bang (to paraphrase) and go one up, one down this week, move hall on next week and hang onto that last trade just in case.

Hall - Menegola
Deledio - Zerrett

Next week:
Hammelmann - Dahlhaus

 

[Tevez17]

Everyone seems lost this week. Lots of big calls to make.

I was going to be conservative but doing that for most of the year has left me stalled around 8k and between 4th and 6th in most of my leagues. So I think I'll go bang bang (to paraphrase) and go one up, one down this week, move hall on next week and hang onto that last trade just in case.

Hall - Menegola
Deledio - Zerrett

Next week:
Hammelmann - Dahlhaus

:Like it, don't see why Menegola doesn't keep his spot, look a real accumulator which Geelong don't really have,

 

[Haychh]

Cox ----> Lycett

That's it. I'm done. Out. Finished. Kaput

2016 officially a write off

 

[captainchardonnay]

:Like it, don't see why Menegola doesn't keep his spot, look a real accumulator which Geelong don't really have,

I agree. Sneaky chance to stay in that team permantly.

 

[Steve]

:Like it, don't see why Menegola doesn't keep his spot, look a real accumulator which Geelong don't really have,

Yeah I hope so, from both a SC and Geelong point of view. We have Caddy to come back in the next week or 2. I hope he's not just holding that spot for him.

 

[lenny]

I might need to hold on Dahl for a week. BE of 188 and I'd really like to see him play a game.

Agreed, saves you a bit of cash and he might take a game or 2 to find his feet again. I just hope Petracca can keep scoring well in the mean time