Agree, mature age body, a lot of contested footy, gets his own ball, cheap, still hungry and out to prove himself to keep his spot, Supercoach heaven, I see all of the planets aligning here
Round 19 Trades
- Thread starter Tevez17
- Start date
Agree, mature age body, a lot of contested footy, gets his own ball, cheap, still hungry and out to prove himself to keep his spot, Supercoach heaven, I see all of the planets aligning here
TomCat
Dual Premiership Coach
Patron '16
Patron '17
Patron '18
Patron '19
Patron '20
Patron '21
Veterans
- Apr 23, 2015
- 2,727
- 2,390
- 113
If you think Menegola keeps his spot who do you think makes room for Caddy? I think Menegola deserves to stay in the team but I'm not sure who gets dropped when Caddy comes back.
TomCat
Dual Premiership Coach
Patron '16
Patron '17
Patron '18
Patron '19
Patron '20
Patron '21
Veterans
- Apr 23, 2015
- 2,727
- 2,390
- 113
I hope you're wrong about McCarthy as I love the kid.
McCarthy plays a completely different role. I can see Cowan out for Caddy... But who goes out for Henderson?
TomCat
Dual Premiership Coach
Patron '16
Patron '17
Patron '18
Patron '19
Patron '20
Patron '21
Veterans
- Apr 23, 2015
- 2,727
- 2,390
- 113
Naismith will now be #1 ruck at swans with Sunclair out.
Holding Hall as i think Tracca and Davis can cover him for a couple more weeks, as for Lids i just don't know who to bring in.
Holding Hall as i think Tracca and Davis can cover him for a couple more weeks, as for Lids i just don't know who to bring in.
I think he plays this week and maybe rests against Essendon. Statement game really. Dogs have been smashed by injury but I think we will want to make sure we get the win with our best 22 available.
Do we need to start a separate Geelong thread??
Gees Naismith looks tempting now even after the price rise.
Grabbed him last week, very happy with his first outing lets hope he won't be required but it is nice to know that he has some form if he is.
Lowrider
Triple Premiership Coach
Patron '16
Patron '17
Patron '18
Patron '19
Patron '20
Patron '21
Veterans
- May 7, 2015
- 3,202
- 3,073
- 113
Naismith was the #1 ruck anyway. Sinclair has been average anyway.
In a way it might hurt Naismith. They'll likely bring in Nankervis to play alongside Naismith. The one who's considered the best forward will be the 2nd ruck and the other will be #1 ruck. It's possible they might consider Naismith the better forward option.
If Naismith has finally turned the corner, look out. And I'm not just talking Supercoach either. Kid could be Sandilands MkII.
Everyone remember how Sandy started his career? A LOT of similarities there.
Everyone remember how Sandy started his career? A LOT of similarities there.
Id move lids i think. Pretty nice team. Maybe consider hall to dahl next week as a dpp swing man too.
I just want him to make through the rest of the season uninjured
Hi all,
5 trades left - 3 games clear on top, going for league win.
Have Lids, Hall and Libba.
Do I hold on trading this week & re-assess next week?
or
Use a trade free up some cash, get Merret in for Lids & look @ trading Libba to Dahl next week dependent on his form?
5 trades left - 3 games clear on top, going for league win.
Have Lids, Hall and Libba.
Do I hold on trading this week & re-assess next week?
or
Use a trade free up some cash, get Merret in for Lids & look @ trading Libba to Dahl next week dependent on his form?
OK so Lids out indefinitely, Hall listed as 1-2, McVeigh looks ginger and 50/50 at best. 4 trades, $6k left. Fighting for top 4 berth in 2 leagues, lose and i could miss finals!!!
So question: Deledio out indefinitely, do I pull the pin and "sideways" trade to: Roo or Lyons. Hold McVeigh n Hall as they "should" return next week (I hope). Hit finals with 3 trades, $60k in bank, hope to win and finish top 4? Makes sense as Lids may not play again this season and Lyon is going up in price, make 60k on that trade.
OR
Do nothing use Silvagni and Petracca as fwd bench cover, Collins as def cover and cross my finger and toes to win.
Im playing 2nd on the ladder who is confirmed top 4 so I don't think he will trade this week.
So question: Deledio out indefinitely, do I pull the pin and "sideways" trade to: Roo or Lyons. Hold McVeigh n Hall as they "should" return next week (I hope). Hit finals with 3 trades, $60k in bank, hope to win and finish top 4? Makes sense as Lids may not play again this season and Lyon is going up in price, make 60k on that trade.
OR
Do nothing use Silvagni and Petracca as fwd bench cover, Collins as def cover and cross my finger and toes to win.
Im playing 2nd on the ladder who is confirmed top 4 so I don't think he will trade this week.
You have to get rid of Lids, as he's not coming back so covering him with your bench is pointless.