R15 Trades

[Mick]

Thoughts on Z.Merrett vs Deledio, need to trade a forward in this week

Tossing up the same, tend to agree with @TomCat on Deledio being proven. In saying that as a bombers fan i would like to have Merrett in my team.

 

[lenny]

Tossing up the same, tend to agree with @TomCat on Deledio being proven. In saying that as a bombers fan i would like to have Merrett in my team.

Went with Merrett in the end. I'm happy so far

 

[Mick]

Nice work @lenny , i will most likely go with Lids but after watching last night i would have liked to take Merrett, just knows how to find the footy.

 

[smirski]

I have two options
Collins - Laird
Ruggles - Mcviegh
Leaving Weitering as D7
Giving me 19 this week

or

Ruggles - Laird
Weitering - Docherty
leaving collins as D7
However left with 18 and Tom Lee as weakest player

 

[cledus32]

I need help with my Defensive upgrade
Boyd vs Laird vs Rance?
I like both Laird and Boyds SOS, But JJ coming back and Suckling playing scares me a bit about Boyd.

HELP

 

[smirski]

I need help with my Defensive upgrade
Boyd vs Laird vs Rance?
I like both Laird and Boyds SOS, But JJ coming back and Suckling playing scares me a bit about Boyd.

HELP

id go laird or boyd. Boyd takes alot of kickins and plays on. Laird has more value as he is cheaper

 

[Brad]

Im a week early on this but Rich to Williams ???
Gws run home is awesum

 

[Dash]

10 Trades 140k. Trade options - 17 playing and Tippa's 37 doesn't help.
Def: Tippa, OMcDonald, RICH, BARTEL, Laird, TUCKER, (H SHAW, COLLINS)
Mid: Priddis, Hanners, Ablett, Pendlebury, R Gray, J Smith, J Trengove, J JANSEN (DANGER, ROCKLIFF, BARLOW)
Ruck: Gawn, S MARTIN, (Grimley)
FWD: Montagna, D Martin, Petracca, Kerridge, Hall, Deledio (WELLS, ZORKO)

I'm thinking to give me 19:
Jansen>Phillips
Tucker>McVeigh
Only leaves me with 9K in the bank. Any other thoughts? Cheers.

 

[k-red17]

I need help with my Defensive upgrade
Boyd vs Laird vs Rance?
I like both Laird and Boyds SOS, But JJ coming back and Suckling playing scares me a bit about Boyd.

HELP

Hey mate I actually have all 3 of those guys. I'd go with Boyd.

Most consistent out of them. Don't think Rance has tonned up for me in the 5-6 weeks since I picked him up and Laird's scores have been a little up and down since returning from his broken toe.

 

[Sniff My UnDees]

Anyone considering JJ? At this stage I've brought in McVeigh for Rich, but am well into PODs come this time of year and am considering JJ instead. Pretty easy run home as well.

Thoughts?

 

[Lowrider]

10 Trades 140k. Trade options - 17 playing and Tippa's 37 doesn't help.
Def: Tippa, OMcDonald, RICH, BARTEL, Laird, TUCKER, (H SHAW, COLLINS)
Mid: Priddis, Hanners, Ablett, Pendlebury, R Gray, J Smith, J Trengove, J JANSEN (DANGER, ROCKLIFF, BARLOW)
Ruck: Gawn, S MARTIN, (Grimley)
FWD: Montagna, D Martin, Petracca, Kerridge, Hall, Deledio (WELLS, ZORKO)

I'm thinking to give me 19:
Jansen>Phillips
Tucker>McVeigh
Only leaves me with 9K in the bank. Any other thoughts? Cheers.

Trades themselves seem fine, can't really fault what you're doing. Jansen has more cash (maybe $100k) to make but depends whether you plan to trade him out later or keep him as bench cover. Smith worth moving on but won't give you an extra player this week.

Other option is moving on Barlow. You do have Kerridge who can cover I guess so you might be able to carry him if all else goes well.

 

[Lowrider]

Anyone considering JJ? At this stage I've brought in McVeigh for Rich, but am well into PODs come this time of year and am considering JJ instead. Pretty easy run home as well.

Thoughts?

Toyed seriously with the idea. Ended up deciding to wait a week or two.

 

[Sniff My UnDees]

Ignore me, I can't make it happen now without burning a trade due to lockout. Duh.

 

[alrighty then]

For me it is either 2 trades (mid rook and Docherty in) or the one (JJ in for Collins). Leaning towards JJ for the POD and the extra trade it leaves me with

 

[Rob86]

I'm going Barlow-Sloan and Hopper-Trengrove this week. It means that I'll have 3 Demons (Petracca and Gawn as well) but I can live with that

 

[tabs]

Trengove out. DAM!!! Have to make 2 trades if i want to have 18 playing.
2nd trade would have been NicNat to Gawn but WC have already played.

 

[Lowrider]

Trengove out. DAM!!! Have to make 2 trades if i want to have 18 playing.
2nd trade would have been NicNat to Gawn but WC have already played.

Bugger. I now only have 21 playing this week....

 

[Dash]

Trades themselves seem fine, can't really fault what you're doing. Jansen has more cash (maybe $100k) to make but depends whether you plan to trade him out later or keep him as bench cover. Smith worth moving on but won't give you an extra player this week.

Other option is moving on Barlow. You do have Kerridge who can cover I guess so you might be able to carry him if all else goes well.

Trengove out now...so any more ideas. If i make two trades i still only field 18, including Tippa's score.

 

[smirski]

i have a feeling trengrove will play for viney. Apparently he didn't train all week

 

[tabs]

i have a feeling trengrove will play for viney. Apparently he didn't train all week

I hope so. Then i have 18 playing and can go Keys and NicNAt to Ward and GAwn (or Martin if i need the cash) next week