Oxley to Rance Good trade or Bad trade

[bxe100]

I am thinking about trading Oxley to Rance this week.
Is this a good trade?
Oxley set to go down in price with breakeven of 124 and Rance has bottomed out with breakeven of 16.
I have Oxley onfield so point gain would be 14 for cost of 17K.

 

[M4TT B8S]

Good Trade, I did Oxley to Yarran last week which gave me 40k and I think Yarran will average 90ish, hopefully more

Definitely time to hop off Oxley I think and Rance is a very good option

 

[doddy2731]

Check out the X v's Y thread, there is some good points on there, and some other options.

PS I'm not keen on Rance.

 

[Fitzroy Guerrilla]

I guess it depends on how much cash you have, how many trades you have remaining and whether or not there are other more important areas to fix up in your team.

The trade should get you more points but if you've got a glaring hole elsewhere it may be a case of priorities.

Oxley looks like he might be on the decline and is somewhat inconsistent, but it's not as if Rance is all that consistent of a scorer either.

 

[bxe100]

doddy2731 I am low on cash who would you recommend max price I can afford is 450K Gibson?
I will check out the X V Y soon. Thanks.

 

[Fitzroy Guerrilla]

If low on cash I think it's a fair trade as long as it doesn't leave you too low on trades.

 

[doddy2731]

I like Simpson $470k on the way up last 3, 77 88 90 should average 95+ from here,Gibbo ok but sporadic scoring is his problem, last 3, 79 89 52. Rance looking at it is good with a low BE but his scoring is all over the shop too, goes from huge 100+ down to a season low 44 3 weeks ago. In the end up to you. Good luck.