Forwards 2016

[tabs]

I have a feeling that Barlow might be a late in so i am starting him over Menadue.

Dam it had to hold Menadue with Papley and BCrouch out

 

[Brad]

I have a feeling that Barlow might be a late in so i am starting him over Menadue.

Dam it had to hold Menadue with Papley and BCrouch out

I had to hold Menapoo aswell with hall paply wells Boyd Ablett laird and Adams out had a few other prioritys damn it

 

[Dino]

I will more than likely take the chance to offload Menadue for McPherson. It would be nice if he was at least 30K more but so be it. It will be good not having to put up with his rubbish. Need to go through the scenarios first though. As the boys said on the podcast, you don't won't to overdo do it with all these mid rookies.

 

[Lowrider]

I'm still holding Menadue on the bench while he's got a heartbeat - DPP is helpful too to help move the other guys around. Waiting for an 80 or two so can hopefully get close to $300k for him.

 

[tabs]

I had to hold Menapoo aswell with hall paply wells Boyd Ablett laird and Adams out had a few other prioritys damn it

I hear you. I had Papley, Hall, GAJ, Rocky, Adams, Barlow, Wells, Grimley, BCrouch out before trades

 

[Tevez17]

I'd need to analyze his run home but Tom Lynch (GCS) is going to be mighty cheap soon GC still a pretty good draw I don't think they need that many players back to be competitive,

 

[Haychh]

Well... Trading out Daniel Wells a couple weeks back has probably made the Top 3 of "Poor supercoach decisions of 2016" it's up there with trading in K Kolodjashnij and M Murphy

 

[tabs]

Surely it time to get rid of Hall now?

 

[Steve]

Surely it time to get rid of Hall now?

Looks like it. No centre bounces attended tonight. Only a couple last week. He's playing forward in a bottom 4 team. That's not good.

 

[Tevez17]

He'll come good but probably not till after the byes.

 

[tabs]

All that money we made off him has now all but gone. Will be about $438k according to tooserious

Kerrigde and Wells almost keepers now for the year

 

[doddy2731]

Kerrigde and Wells almost keepers now for the year

Totally agree, but i'd remove the almost.

 

[bat]

Kerridge definitely not a keeper for mine, Wells is though.

Can't have 4/11 scores in the 60s from a keeper.

But heck, he's probably more likely to stay than Hall at this stage :|

 

[doddy2731]

But heck, he's probably more likely to stay than Hall at this stage :|

I'll happy swining Kerridge between my Fwrd and Mid bench for cover. He's shown enough to me that he is M9-F8 worthy.
As for Hall, 1 word Goodbye.

 

[Tevez17]

I'm baffled by this Hall hate especially when then talking up Kerridge who's averaging less, scored less overall despite playing one more game and shown a lower ceiling, I understand Hall is underperforming at the moment but the reasons why are clear and imo are temporary.

 

[tabs]

I'm baffled by this Hall hate especially when then talking up Kerridge who's averaging less, scored less overall despite playing one more game and shown a lower ceiling, I understand Hall is underperforming at the moment but the reasons why are clear and imo are temporary.

What are the clear reasons he is underperforming?

Im thinking of trading him as as isnt in the centre bounces any more

 

[Tevez17]

What are the clear reasons he is underperforming?

Im thinking of trading him as as isnt in the centre bounces any more

His injury has changed his role, but he's still playing which to me says a couple weeks a he'll be right, GCs draw is still one of the best if/when they get their act together personally I can see him coming home very strong.

If you want to trade him go nuts just saying why I'm not going too.

 

[bat]

He had 2 tackles in the game with the 2nd most tackles ever. His shoulder is giving him problems, yes. But his defense hasn't been up to scratch and he'd probably be dropped if GC had a full team and he kept this up for a couple more weeks.

 

[thejuddernaut]

His injury has changed his role, but he's still playing which to me says a couple weeks a he'll be right, GCs draw is still one of the best if/when they get their act together personally I can see him coming home very strong.
go nuts just saying why I'm not going too.

I tend to agree. If your biggest problem this week for rnd 12 trading is hall then you must have a bloody great team. In my case think brown and hewett along with collins and jansen require the effort this week

If you want to trade him

 

[Tevez17]

He had 2 tackles in the game with the 2nd most tackles ever. His shoulder is giving him problems, yes. But his defense hasn't been up to scratch and he'd probably be dropped if GC had a full team and he kept this up for a couple more weeks.

I don't think he's being asked to tackle at the moment, had a crook shoulder for 3 weeks and his tackle numbers are down for 3 weeks (4.2ave vs 2ave).