Brodie Smith

[TwentyThree]

I brought Maynard in last week before his first price rise, not great JS tho.

 

[doddy2731]

Who's a good Saad replacment if he doesn't come back this week, D7 who must have mid capability, playing but cheap as possible?

What about Maynard from the Pies, should hold his spot and is DEF/MID

Just saw Twentythree's post sorry for the double up.

 

[doddy2731]

Who's a good Saad replacment if he doesn't come back this week, D7 who must have mid capability, playing but cheap as possible?

Saad apparently is going to miss this weekend again.

 

[Prospector]

Saad apparently is going to miss this weekend again.

#dislike

 

[M4TT B8S]

Wew! Don't have Saad traded all my 300k+ rookies around the byes (apart from Oxley, but he's long gone now too)

 

[Tevez17]

Was keeping Saad just as Mid Def cover but with McGovern going down after losing 150k I'm in a bit of a pickle with S Edwards looking like he gets a gig off the bench this week,

Not sure what to do though don't really have the cash for a real top Defender, Malcheski or Smith look dodgy if cheap options.

 

[doddy2731]

Just throwing it out there but what about Savage, Kelly or Howe?

Howe $335 BE 2, top score last week 121 avg 75
Savage $364 BE 30 top score last week 111 avg 72
Kelly $343 BE 41 top score last week 106 avg 75

 

[Prospector]

Just throwing it out there but what about Savage, Kelly or Howe?

Howe $335 BE 2, top score last week 121 avg 75
Savage $364 BE 30 top score last week 111 avg 72
Kelly $343 BE 41 top score last week 106 avg 75

Be Kelly put of those, surely?

 

[doddy2731]

Probably right Pros, but i don't mind Savage as a left of center though.

 

[Tevez17]

Thinking maybe Kelly or just hold, have Maynard, can afford Murphy or Hurley but will empty the bank and only 2 trades lef after that. Do have playing rookie cover on each line.

 

[M4TT B8S]

Thinking maybe Kelly or just hold, have Maynard, can afford Murphy or Hurley but will empty the bank and only 2 trades lef after that. Do have playing rookie cover on each line.

My attitude this year has been go hard or go home, I'm on 2 trades with 28/30 playing (ruck bench will never play and McLean is the other not playing who won't come back)
so far it's served me fairly well, sitting at 707th in my second year of supercoach, no doubt some credit goes out to the boys on the podcast

I say splash out on Murphy

 

[Tevez17]

Just looking through the 90 averagers like Murphy I just justify to myself not just going to Kelly and keeping my bench swing open, for Kelly is a 90 average aswell just had injuries and sub vest big assumption that those things won't happen again but when he's on the park he's playing well and I think it's worth the punt.
This is all assuming he's not the sub today of course haha.

 

[doddy2731]

Savage 100+ today, keep an eye on him.