Search results

New patron of the podcast, how do I access the exclusive forum?

It's just a few writers having a stab at rd 1 teams, I wouldn't put too much stock into it.

Calm down, Bont isn't a once in a decade player. I'm just thinking not every rookie has the "second year blues" and young Oliver could be a good stepping stone to a GAJ come round 9. But I can do the same with a rookie anyway. I really like Oliver but you're right, maybe next year.

Both if you can afford it

He might do a Bont and breakout this year

Zerrett

What happened to Barlow?

One up one down this week, question is, Macpherson or Brand? Anyone know much about these two? Macpherson DE% worries me but so does Brands job security and the fact he is a tall key position defender.

Hopper has played 1 game. I think everyone needs to calm down and get some more information.

And as far as downgrade targets go this week he's the only one I'm potentially looking at. Petracca a better option obviously but I won't go a week early on him. Dusty looks to have bottomed out so I may bring him in.

Can find the ball, but tends to butcher it a fair bit. Job security is hard to gauge. There are far worse performers in the team at the moment and if Langdon's ankle doesn't come up he should definitely have a place in the side for at least a few more weeks.

Fyfe to Priddis or Hannebery for me. Hannebery yet to put a foot wrong and I would back Priddis to get back his mantle of Mr. Consistent. Had a down game when they got crushed by Hawthorn and when they played at an unknown SCG so a slight discount for Priddis might just give him the nod over...

Im hoping Naitanui goes big against Hampson

Obviously Hartley isn't a "must-have", but a lot of people are passing on him. Bad timing/other pressing trades? Unsure on his JS? Waiting for Ruggles? I actually really like the look of Hartley. Averaged 78 in the NAB and 70 in his first two games. Not a top-up player so arguably should be...

Despite playing some very soft opposition in the first 3 rounds I think it's safe to assume I was wrong about Aaron Hall - he is a jet. Am I wasting a trade if I go Sam Gray > Hall?

Gawn 172 with 7 frees against! :eek:

I don't have injuries apart from Rich, I've got all the must-have rookies and I'm reasonably happy with the rest of my premiums. Ive missed a few in Parker/Hall/JJ but you can't get them all and I'm not convinced sideways trading Barlow and/or Rich to get them in is a great move. I have enough...

Holding Barlow and Rich. Should I be trading out Gresham for Hartley (via DPP) just to get a correction done this week or have another look at Hartley. 30 trades still in the bank I'm kind of just looking for something to do. Should I sit on my hands or just make the Gresham>Hartley trade this...

Swans would be taking a giant step backwards playing McGlynn. Papley is the future, it's his spot to lose IMO

Agreed, he should be peaking at 27-28 years old but he just seems too slow for the way the game is being played right now. Maybe it's more of a Freo problem than a Michael Barlow problem. Let's keep in mind they have just played two of the quickest moving sides in the competition in the Suns and...