Search results

1 Montagna 2 Budwa 3 Bartel Based on score ceilings, management over remaining games and only joey 1st as he has mpp over buddy which may be handy come bye time

If you traded him in off the big game scores and you expected one every week then your either a geelong supporter or a lunatic. Guys with very high ceilings in good (not great) teams must come in on an average points over year school of thought, not on an "he's good for 120 every week" basis...

I rate bartel and mcveigh equally above rance for avg for rest of year but i expect them to miss games being managed and rance to play all of them. Raises the old question of Avg vs total. I would go rance as im a total boy.

I think i am the only one in the SCC community who doesnt have danger. I had parker from the get go and did watd as first upgrade so probably negated the danger effect. With his price dropping now im thinking of jumping in but then again i didn't pick fyfe this year and it worked. Might watch...

My "issue" if it is one at all with my rookies in the mids is the fact that they are Smith, Gresham, Hewett and Davis. Either didn't start round one ie: Smith or have been dropped Gresham and Davis, think Hewett missed one as well, which has limited cash generation but my main problem is that...

What happens when lobbe returns? Would think Dbj better placed as a keeper D6 if your looking at that sort of option. Dbj hasnt put a foot wrong, has great de %, looks like a footballer and all within 4 games. Js not an issue. Trengrove was great last week but over his career he's patchy at...

I think i have talked myself into mills - cripps and weitering to docherty. Which will leave me, unlike a couple of guys above, only having to field one rookie in the mids - smith and i still don't have danger! So ultra aggressive for me too over next few weeks as only have 2d 1m and 2f rookies...

I have him and happy i do. I think top 6 fwds this year. Playing mid, racks up possies, wont get tagged, woosha will get as much mid time into him to help with next year. Solid selection and to be honest speculative with no conviction from me when i did it but very pleased so far.

I am now looking at mills to danger and possibly davis to brand via dpp. Not sold on his js but it gives me dpp flexibility fwd - def again, the bye structure is right and i get to hold weitering for def loophole which may be useful, davis played well in neafl apparently and after GC got a touch...

5. Sorry missed one. Hard to know as everyone has diff opinion on who is best. My first mid upgrade was ward 2, dahlhaus and this week will welcome danger and neale i think. Danger obviously highest scorer but the value in my picks and the rise in ranking with no danger means possibly a choice...

Answers - 1. No - i rate Matheson better and think they did as more nab time and better scores than keays just the broken jaw stopped him and hes been back in neafl for last couple weeks so expect to see him soon. If keays was dpp then i would lean his way. 2. Trengove was great yesterday and...

If memory serves me correctly both he and joey started well last year and although not finishing off as well were still in top fwds on avg. Big fan of them both as players and loyal servants to club but with hall, lynch, dusty, jroo all r13 bye players and at their price comparison think its a...

Im expecting 300k and considering weitering to him as a left of centre idea, then again may hold him for loophole use and for D7 if possible once team done or d6 if things go pear shaped.

Was thinking that could be an option with him seemingly going to ruck with no lobbe gor twelve weeks. Is it a silly thought to bring him in as a cash generation tool to move on at bye time as all other real cheap rookie def i think have shaky js?

My rants were indicative of my love for the jumper and my disdain for MM. Very happy with Bolts as coach, can see game plan and ideas but need better skills. On another note - i am a big cripps fan, not only for being a blue but for his availability to people and persona (he's mate with a...

After reading about everyones bad luck with C selection, bar the Gawn choice, i thought i would have my input. I finally pulled the right rein and made pendles vc and as i had smith's 49 as my e had to toss up if to put davis on the ground take 142 and hope that parker didnt go huge and that...

I think he will hold his spot as pies chances for finals are gone and today i believe he said cloke will need to earn spot back after being late out this weekend. That puts cox in for at least 2 or 3 except if gault plays stars and comes straight in after a week.

They run into the form team of the competition next week in the blues.....so maybe hold off a week.

Unfortunatley not prossie, he was playing round one and i thought why not. Now I have dropped the not and only think Why?

Yes i have Petracca, have from the start of the season. As for Keays I liked his effort but think his js shakier than smiths. The other factor in play is that this week Cox will give me a rnd 13 bye in the rucks so he can partner goldy and gawn the following weeks rnd 14 and 15. Think I will...