Trades before round 4

[doddy2731]

Thinking of trading Naughton out to Richards for cash generation?
Thoughts?

I wouldn't, kind of a nothing trade.
Not enough coin to make it worth it imo and a trade lost, Naughton maybe a slow burn burn but but your only going to pocket around $60k and at least you know he will be named each week.

Good luck with what ever you choose.

 

[Ice Cold Beverage]

Armitage out is a pain, but holding. Ryan to Crowden is the only trade for me this week

 

[doddy2731]

Armitage out is a pain, but holding. Ryan to Crowden is the only trade for me this week

I feel it too, at least a good loop option now with the last game of the round.

 

[Lowrider]

Chris Scott on Henderson - "There's no real update there other than to say we don't expect to have him back in the next few weeks."

And Taylor still an unknown timeframe .

Sounds like Henry isn't going anywhere in a hurry ...

 

[Orallus_Maximus]

Nothing listed on the Giants website yet.

I'm considering straight swap Kelly to TMitch. Kelly has been a bit off - makes me wonder if the groin has been the issue all along? The other side of me is saying keep trades and don't trade out premos...

 

[Steve]

I'm considering straight swap Kelly to TMitch. Kelly has been a bit off - makes me wonder if the groin has been the issue all along? The other side of me is saying keep trades and don't trade out premos...

I've made this trade. Mitchell needs to be in every decent side at some stage this year. Kelly maybe not. A groin niggle is enough to limit him to a 105 avg this year.

 

[Centroprise]

I'm considering straight swap Kelly to TMitch. Kelly has been a bit off - makes me wonder if the groin has been the issue all along? The other side of me is saying keep trades and don't trade out premos...

Considered it but like you chose to hold trades and not side swap premos.

 

[Machineman]

I would not be side swapping premo's for a 1 week injury, We need to use trades for making money to complete our team, the better our cash gen trades, the better our final team.

 

[Steve]

I dont see it as a side swap. Kelly had had a slight role change, playing a lot more high half forward instead of in the guts. Possession count has dropped right off, and now hes not fit.

I held Shaw all of last year saying "it's ok, he will come good" when all the signs showed otherwise. I'm not doing that with Kelly.

 

[alrighty then]

I dont see it as a side swap. Kelly had had a slight role change, playing a lot more high half forward instead of in the guts. Possession count has dropped right off, and now hes not fit.

I held Shaw all of last year saying "it's ok, he will come good" when all the signs showed otherwise. I'm not doing that with Kelly.

I like this. It's funny, most players in the past that I have held, I regretted. If you have that feeling, then move swiftly. Kelly I haven't been watching and the role change could be due to his injury? But if Mitchell is good for your team I don't think you will look back, maybe get Kelly back in later when he drops.