Search results

He's a funny one McCarthy, that job security is pretty sweet his average won't be great but he'll no doubt kick a bag at some point. At this stage I'm happy to have 2 200k rookies though have recently dropped Swallow.

How many keeper do you think you have? Similar team to mine I'm concerned I'm starting too many maybe keepers.

I'm really coming around to Tom Lynch as a selection from the start it's just that Bye that's stopping me at his stage.

I was surprised the boys in the podcast were so keen on Macrae, I just don't see in the Dogs system where the improvement comes from, he can rack them up & can tackle but he just doesn't win that much ball himself, just like Gaff at west coast really good footballer but game just doesn't quite...

I'm with you hear, I'll still take Dahlhaus because he scores well in both the mid and forward roles, Bont is really the only other one I would consider and with an interrupted pre-season I won't be starting with him. As far as Top 10 goes I'm so unsure, Roo and Dalh but after that who knows, I...

A Few Good Menzels is in. o_O

It's just job security that's the worry, he's loved at the club, seen as a real leader, got a very SC friendly style but I'd need to see/hear Chris Scott say that he get's his chance this season.

Greene, Sandi & Hanners

I started the pre-season with Gawn/Hickey, then Gawn/Goldy, very briefing Hickey/Sandi, then Gawn/Sandi & spent the last week with Nankervis/Sandi, I've now brought Gawn back in with Sandilands I do think that's the best combo, Spencer doesn't worry me too much & I'm happy to pay a little extra...

Isn't it unlimtied trades in R1? you'd still need an option to trade too that hasn't played but can cover yourself a bit

Is Tarranto worth the cash now with the extra JS of Coniglio's injury?

Geez Hickey was good yesterday, He was in my team a month ago looked pretty poor in the other 2 games

Aaron Black played VFL yesterday that points to him being a little unlikely to play R1.

My concern is what happens when Weitering* goes back.

Yeah not there for me.

Clear Team

I worry that he's only gone over 100 3 times in his career and the 2 times last season he kicked bags of 5 & 6 for scores of 102 and 124, I think they'll be a spike in his number this season maybe jump from 65 to 80 something like that.

Can see where you are coming from with Swallow, I respect anyone who's starting without O'Meara &/or Swallow, I think i'd just gotten used to my mids with Swallow at M8 & it's going to take a little bit for me to be comfortable with a rookie there.

With a bit of a change around it's now more Swallow Vs Roughead & I think that's an easier one, Swallow unlikely to be a keeper in his position where'as Roughy is a chance at least, also I think I'd rather have SPP on field than a 130K rookie up forward.

My concern is what happens when goes back.