Search results

Haha it's just dawned on me how stupid of a question that was. :oops::rolleyes:

Haven't really liked what I've seen from Mcrae so far

JOM or Swallow?

There's one guy I'm dying to pick, I think he has the role, for the right team, points per minute fantastic, improved nicely season on season but is it stupid with all these injury affected guys to be trying to land a break out?

Can't disagree with much of that, my worry is to make 200k he has to average pretty much 100 for half a season, just seems a tough ask at this stage I'd prefer to take the punt on Swallow to average 90 odd and make me 150k by his bye upgarde him then or if he's doing well keep him through the 3...

No doubt he's a gun but he's at least 13 points off being a keeper on history and coming off 2 years without footy, huge rest risk & obviously injury risk, saying "should" be a keeper seems a little over the top to me.

One G Ablett could be a POD this season.

Yeah that Bye could hurt, but structure wise I like most people seem to be going at least one more premo mid but that makes at least one other line look very weak.

I personally just don't see the ongoing commitment being too realistic for a keeper league despite how cool it sounds. I'd be keen to do a one season draft if anyone else was, not necessarily SC.

2/0/6 6/1/4 2/0/1 3/1/4 Don't like it but its this currently

Think you've nailed the feedback really, probably just asking too much for all these blokes to take the next step that being said it's a fun team!

Love that setup except they do all share a bye.

So you're thinking more a gradual improvement across the board at Melbourne rather than someone/s breaking out, Salem was probably the only other guy i was looking at having averaged 74 over 10 games 2 season ago with a 16 in there.

Oliver?

Is Petracca the new Bont in that he can become a premo in only his second season?

Team name: A Few Good Menzels (previously MOT) 2016 ranking: 13717 (top 6%) Any other rankings before 2016: 21000ish SCC league in 2016 (if applicable): was in one but can't remember the name maybe Supercoachcoach11.

Hrovat is going to tempt me all pre-season I can just tell, I really don't like his role at the moment far too much fwd pocket not enough half-forward / wing but he's clean and classy when he get's it I can see CD being a fan, stinks of an 80 ave it's just not quite enough at 300K.

Yeah think 200K is a bit steep for what looks like a 60odd ave.

Think I've a little bit about midpricers over the last year or so, I started with Sam Gray and Jesse Lonergan last season & 2 things they had in common for me is that I really knew little about them I was going off decent finishes to previous season & strong pre-season form but I'd never really...