Search results

  1. T

    Round 9 Trades

    Sorry guys, not to be annoying but does anybody have any thoughts on the above? Any advice would be great. Thanks
  2. T

    Round 9 Trades

    Potentially thinking of even holding SPP and trading Hannan -> Myers cos Hannan won't be making his BE of 53. But that will net me 66k which I'm worried might not be worth the trade.
  3. T

    Round 9 Trades

    So my team reads as follows: Laird, Shaw, Hibberd, Marchbank, Otten, Newman (Berry, Stewart) Danger, JPK, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, Oliver, J.Lloyd, Steele, SPP (Barrett, Balic, Hibberd) Martin, Sandilands (Strnadica) Dahlhaud, Macrae, Nank, Heeney, Higgins, WHE (Hannan, Parsons) So I have 310k in the...
  4. T

    Round 9 Trades

    Why? Granted his BE is still around 100, I think he represents great value at 510k. I personally think, this year more than ever, that finding value is critical given the limited cash generation from rookies.
  5. T

    Round 9 Trades

    Move up 16k places to about 8k with a round of 2390. Pretty rapt. Feel my season is starting to take shape. What are people's thoughts on Myers? I'm not sure he's the lock that everyone thinks. I have 310k spare and looking at a possible double upgrade. Thinking possibly: Otten > Cripps WHE >...
  6. T

    Round 3 Trades

    I'm moving Taranto on. Just not convinced with his job security, and I want Higgins in. So my trades are: Bowes > Higgins Taranto > WHE Will have 37k leftover. Didn't quite have enough cash to upgrade another cheaper rookie, like Pickett, to WHE, as I really want Higgins in. Was thinking of...
  7. T

    Round 1 discussion, scores + more

    Bit harsh, he has had a limited preseason and was rusty cos of it. I wouldn't worry, he will come good.
  8. T

    Players X. vs Y. vs Z.

    Now that I have felt obligated to get Gawn into the ruck, I am now faced with the following choice for structure: M.Crouch v J.Kelly Thoughts?
  9. T

    2017 Rate My Team

    Hey everyone. Good luck to all again. So after a lot of deliberating I think I'm finally set on my structure and happy with this side. I'm taking the risk in the ruck this year. I've been reluctant to do so in the past and decided to go Set and Forget but I think there's real value here. Any...
  10. T

    Round 4 Trades

    I have B.Crouch, who I am going to hold for another week then potentially down grade to either Ruggles or Petracca. Can use him as a loophole option this week. Having Mills as my M8 is a real concern. And I have Crouch, Davis and Gresham on the pine which doesn't help. Anyone planning on...
  11. T

    Rd 3 trades

    Think I'm going to hold Barlow now. Rich/Rocky are bigger problems at this stage. I'm just not confident at all on Rich now without Beams/Rocky. He has clearly demonstrated he is horrible with a tag. Rocky is gun but his body can't be trusted at this stage with a limited preseason and clearly...
  12. T

    Rd 3 trades

    Yeah I was planning on holding Rocky too as he won't play but I want Parker. I can only get Parker if I trade out Rocky so just hoping Rich misses so i can hold him without a price change happening next wk. Otherwise if Rich plays I will possibly look at holding Rocky and doing Rich>JJ and...
  13. T

    Rd 3 trades

    3 correction trades on premiums to start the season is a worry. But I don't like what I've seen of Barlow - he looks slow and as if the game has passed him by. Rocky can't stay fit. And watching the way Rich handled the tag on Sat was embarrassing. Don't think I can ride that rollercoaster of...
  14. T

    Rd 3 trades

    At this stage, I'm looking at: Rocky>Parker Barlow>JJ (via DPP) Praying that Rich misses this week so he doesn't go down in price and I can upgrade him to one of Martin or Zorko next week.
  15. T

    Round 2 Discussion

    So is everyone convinced Barlow is on the outer this week?
  16. T

    Rate My Team

    Changed Loersch to King from my initial post (loophole option obviously) as considered the fact that Ablett and Loersch play in the same side so if I were to use Ablett's score as a VC and want to use the loophole I obviously won't be able to use Loersch. Melbourne play 10 Sunday games (equal...
  17. T

    Forwards 2016

    I think that move would pay off. Generally Dusty is known the throw the odd shocker in here or there so I'm absolutely certain you will get hime on the cheap. Not to mention the value is in the fwd line this year IMO. I think 3 rookie mids on field is too much of a risk. I've decided to start...
  18. T

    Rate My Team

    Ok. So after so much fiddling around for the last few days. I'm pretty sure set on this lineup. I've decided to take a bit more risk this year and go for value the FWD line. DEF: Shaw, Laird, Johannisen, Harwood, Weitering, Hartley (Brown, Ruggles) MID: Dangerfield, Ablett, Gray, Rockliff...
  19. T

    Starting team structure

    K.Simpson
  20. T

    Starting team structure

    Just not sure whether to go Libba at M6 and have 2 of Mills/Oliver/Parish or go for Libba at M5 and have all 3. At the moment, in my mind it's basically: Priddis + Parker + Simpson (Libba at M6) vs Shaw + Fyfe + Oliver + 165k left (Libba at M5) Is anyone convinced starting 3 rookies on...