Search results

Thanks for the thoughts. I too like Melksham, nabbed him in my draft league and very pleased. I'll mull it over and see how it goes, otherwise pretty settled with my team despite a few last moves haha. Thanks for your perspective and good luck :)

DED: Laird, Hibberd, Siciliy, Naughton, Doedee, Murray, (Finlayson/Murphy) MID: Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Kelly (Tim), (Banfield/Barry/Holman). RUCK: Marton, Gawn, (Lavender) FWD: Henney, Billings, Smith, Lobb, Christensen, Fritsch, (Giles-Landon/Ryan) I view my...

Can't decide on where to go here, keen for another perspective. Josh Kelly (MID) Lobb (FWD) $29.2k vs Dangerfield (MID) Bonner (DEF) $47.2k. The risk sits in Bonner vs Lobb. I view Bonner purely as a stepping stone, where as Lobb a chance as a keeper (no.1 Ruck, yet limited pre-season)...

Scores 57 against the Blues. I've had him in and out of my side. The scoring potential is there, but it's these poor games that scare me off.

Thinking Wells to Dahlhaus and Shiel to Bontempeli, thoughts? Luxury trades and will still have 2 left.

Hewitt to Trengove Menadue to Rose Tippa to Austin Cash in the bank, 19 on field. Next week bring in 1 of Rance/Docherty, then one of Montagna/Deledio, then an additional downgrade.

Very good thought, it's unlikely the Gray goes up significantly so that he's out of reach next week. Tuckers an interesting one, I'm apprehensive with 2 Freo boys in my backline, I'm comfortable with Collins JS. I'm thinking wait a week as Kennedy won't go down, see how Trengove is and maybe...

I'm on-board Kerridge hitting his BE this week too. Unfortunately this is also the source of my troubles as Kerridge is the best candidate for me to get Robbie Gray in this week. Essentially there are a lack of downgrade targets.... I went early on Collins last week, but not keen on Paine...

Takes Collins 59 or Ruggles v Carlton?

Hey Guys, On this topic what's everyone's BYE strategy (if at all)? I plan heavily for the BYEs, and let it factor into my choices. I currently have 9, 11 & 10 players missing for rounds 13, 14, 15. Taking into consideration who's likely to play I project to have 19, 18 & 19 players actually...

Went Selwood as a POD VC, clearly didn't come off. Thoughts on C options? Have Gaz, Parker, Gawn, Shaw, Martin as my remaining options. edit: Goldy is there too. Leaning Parker vs Richmond tonight (no Kennedy means potentially more Pill for Parker and Hanners).

Nice Move, Eyeing off Martin next week probably. I think Benken will get the 65+. J.McVeigh is an interesting one, got a couple more weeks to scope him out.

2207, Cracked into the top 1000 this week. Selwood and Parker debuting in my team this week (for Fyfe and Gray), Parker with the C the real hero. Had the most effective team on field bar Tippa for M.Brown which would've netted me another 35, and Weitering getting injured for 23 over Dea's 39...

The voice of reason... :) I think I will mate. Pendles suits my BYEs better (although this can be worked out over the next x rounds before the BYEs). Geelong's run home looks tasty! Lock it in M4TT B8S!

Gray to Selwood or Pendles? Thoughts....?

Yeah that's true, but I think it's just another factor that has a positive contribution here. You've got a 22 years old probably coming off a rookie contract + extension. This will be an opportunity for his first big contract (both length and dollars). It's not like we've got a 27/28 year old...

I'm more inclined to this way of thinking. I think holding onto Gray just 'costs' too much. Can I ask the reasoning for Holding Gray? I'm interested as I'm in the same situation. If Gray was 2 weeks I'd be more tempting to hold. Have you traded heavily to this point?

I like the pick too, for a few reasons. Obviously job security is a non-issue, but he's role will be solid as he in youngster and Freo need to value that. Then there is the no Fyfe situation which only helps. Also he's in a contract year/free agent. Meaning he'll be super motivated to prove...

T. Mitch or Sloane are solid options with good scoring history, are you still shy of the $563.1 for Cotchin because he could be another option? Other PODs you could afford could be: Hanley (1.9%) @ $537.7k Viney (2.4%) @ $500.1k Treloar (4.8%) @ 543.3k. It looks like your decision is POD/value...

I think the prevailing logic you've got here is the overwhelming value he presents. Even at $580k say he has an 'underwhelming' rest of season and averages 110, that's still a great result. I'm ranked quite well and haven't really been bothered by having him, but to maintain that rank I think...